TRS 2 to TRS 3: 4 Reasons You Shouldn’t Switch Plans

Every January, members of TRS Plan 2 get a letter from DRS. It says you can move from TRS 2 to TRS 3, and it usually puts a nice big dollar figure in front of you to make the switch sound tempting.

So should you do it? My answer is almost always the same: no. I’ve talked with a lot of teachers who made this move, or who know someone who did. Every single one of them regretted it. They didn’t realize what they were giving up, and they ended up with less income, more stress, more taxes to plan around, and more fees.

In this post I’ll walk through exactly why I feel this way. We’ll look at real numbers, a few simple tables, and the questions you should ask before you sign anything. If you want to talk through your own situation, you can also schedule a personal meeting with me.


The TRS 2 to TRS 3 switch is permanent

The first thing to know is that this move can’t be undone. Once you go from Plan 2 to Plan 3, that’s it. You can’t change your mind next year and go back.

Whenever someone hands you an offer like this, ask one question: who does this really help? Is it in my best interest, or the state’s? Notice that the state lets you move from Plan 2 to Plan 3, but never from Plan 3 to Plan 2. That one-way door is a pretty good clue about who comes out ahead.

Why the state wants you to move

On TRS 2, your pension is 2% of your average salary for every year you work. On TRS 3, the pension part is only 1% per year. When you switch, you cut the state’s future pension bill in half.

You take the lump sum and invest it yourself. You also take on the investment risk, the fees, and the tax planning, which saves the state a lot of money.

A worked example: what you give up by switching

Let’s use simple numbers. Say your average salary over your top five years is $100,000, and you have 30 years in the system.

ItemStay on TRS 2Switch to TRS 3
Pension factor per year2%1%
Years of service3030
Percent of salary as pension60%30%
Yearly pension on $100,000 average$60,000$30,000
Yearly income you now have to make up yourself$0$30,000

By switching, you save the state $30,000 a year, every year you’re retired. Stretch that over 30 years of retirement and add in the cost-of-living adjustments you would have been entitled to, and the state saves well over a million dollars because you made this move.

Where that lump sum really comes from

Here’s the part most people miss. The money in that letter usually isn’t extra money. It’s basically your own money handed back to you: what you already paid into TRS 2, plus interest.

You just never saw it, because TRS 2 is a defined benefit plan. Your statement shows a future pension, not a dollar balance, and DRS doesn’t make that number easy to find. If you asked to cash out of Plan 2, it would be about the same amount they’re offering you to switch. So the state isn’t losing money out of pocket. It’s giving you your own account and taking away half your pension.


Risk 1: all the investment risk is now yours

Once the lump sum lands in your Plan 3 account, you’re in full control of how it’s invested. If you don’t pick anything, it goes into the target date fund that lines up with age 65.

Target date funds are a product of the investment industry. They take a guess at what you’ll want at 65. More often than not, they carry more risk than people realize. And a lot of teachers don’t work until 65. Many retire at 62 with 30 years in. If your fund is built for a longer time horizon than you actually have, you’re taking more risk than you think.

On Plan 3, 100% of the risk is yours.

Risk 2: taxes on the money down the road

You still owe tax on that Plan 3 money at some point. How much depends on what tax brackets and deductions look like later, what your income is, and how you take the money out.

If you pull too much out in one year, you can jump up a couple of brackets. That means more tax withheld, and it can also cause more of your Social Security to be taxed. With a pension, the income comes in steady. With an account, you have to plan every withdrawal.

Risk 3: you start paying investment fees

On TRS 2, you contribute around 8% of your pay. There are no fees on that from your point of view. The money grows at a guaranteed rate, and the state puts money in too.

On Plan 3, you pay fees on your invested account, and those fees go to the state’s investment program. So by switching, you saved the state your pension, and now you’re also paying them to manage your account. Depending on the fund you pick, fees run roughly 0.1% to 0.48% a year. That’s not terribly expensive on its own.

How Plan 3 fund fees compare

The Washington State Investment Board (WSIB) runs all the investments for the state plans. That includes the TAP fund (where roughly two thirds of teachers still have their money), the target date funds, large cap, small cap, the bond fund, and everything else on the menu. WSIB manages these itself instead of using outside providers like Fidelity or Vanguard.

Washington’s plans aren’t covered by ERISA, the federal law that governs how many private employers run their retirement plans. ERISA has rules about fund costs and investment advice that these state plans don’t have to follow. When I made this video, the Plan 3 target date funds cost about four times as much as comparable Vanguard target date funds, which were around 0.08%.

ExampleAmount
Plan 3 account balance in a target date fund$300,000
Approximate yearly fund fee taken from the accountAbout $1,000
Fee on TRS 2 pension contributions$0

The fee comes out of your account automatically. A fee isn’t bad by itself. The point is to know what you’re paying and what you’re getting for it. On TRS 2, you pay nothing for a guaranteed income. On Plan 3, you pay a fund fee and you still carry all the risk.

Risk 4: you have to save more to catch up

Getting a lump sum doesn’t mean you’re done. You gave up half your pension, so now you have to keep building the account to make up for it.

On TRS 2, your contribution rate is set for you, currently around 8%. On Plan 3, you choose a rate: 5%, 7%, 10%, up to 15%. Whatever you pick, you’re locked into it. If you pick 5% to free up some cash for paying things off, you’ve locked yourself into a lower savings rate. Going from about 8% down to 5% is very unlikely to replace the pension you just gave up, so you’d have to save extra somewhere else on top of it.


How much do you need in Plan 3 just to break even?

Back to our example. TRS 2 would have paid $60,000 a year. After switching, TRS 3 pays $30,000 a year for life. You have to make up the missing $30,000 on your own.

To figure out how big your account needs to be, divide the $30,000 by the percent you plan to pull out each year. That’s your break-even balance.

ApproachYearly payout rateBalance needed for $30,000 a year
Invested, 4% withdrawals4%About $750,000
Invested, 5% withdrawals5%About $600,000
TAP annuity at age 62 (Dec 2022 rate)5.83%About $514,000
TAP annuity at age 65 (Dec 2022 rate)6.3%About $476,000

Using the market to replace the income

If you plan to take 4% a year from your Plan 3 account, you’d need about $750,000 saved. That’s just to get back to even with what you gave up. $750,000 looks like a big, exciting number on a statement, but it isn’t extra. Only the money above that is truly extra.

And that $750,000 has to stay around that level to keep producing $30,000 a year. When the market drops, like it did in 2022, the balance goes down too. Then you have two choices. You can cut your income, which might mean skipping a vacation or spending less at Christmas. Or you can keep your income the same and pull a bigger percentage out of a smaller account.

If the down market lasts a while, that percentage keeps creeping up. That’s how people run out of money. It can work, but you need a real strategy. If you take 5% a year instead, you only need about $600,000, but you’re leaning harder on the market.

Using the TAP annuity for guaranteed income

A lot of people don’t want their retirement income tied to the market. Picture going to work and hearing, “The market’s down 20% this month, so no paycheck.” That wouldn’t fly at your job, and it doesn’t fly well in retirement either.

Guaranteed income means an annuity. The state offers the TAP annuity to Plan 3 members. In December 2022, DRS released new rates: about 5.83% at age 62. That means for every $100,000 you put in, you get about $5,830 a year for life, plus a 3% cost-of-living adjustment. To replace $30,000 a year, you’d need about $514,000. At 65 the payout rises to about 6.3%, so you’d need about $476,000.

Because the income is guaranteed, the market risk goes away and you need less money. But think about what just happened. You gave up the pension for more money and control, took all the risk, paid the fees, and then handed the money back to the state for a guaranteed check. You’re where you started, or worse if you missed the goal. And most people near $500,000 don’t want to hand it all over and have no liquid savings left.

The fine print on the TAP plan

  • To buy the TAP annuity, the money has to come from your TRS 3 account. You can’t use cash, your 403(b), your Roth IRA, or your DCP. (Check DRS’s current rules before counting on this either way.)
  • The rates above were based on December 2022, when interest rates were rising. Rates could be very different when you retire. If rates drop and the state pays 5% instead of 6%, your plan could fall apart.
  • You need a good savings rate, and you have to keep your emotions in check. Going to cash because of a scary headline can wreck the plan.
  • You need the market to cooperate. A big drop right before you retire could leave you without enough to buy the annuity at all.

A better way: stay on TRS 2 and save on the side

Staying on Plan 2 doesn’t mean you can’t save anywhere else. As a school district employee, you have the DCP and 403(b) plans, and you can save into them no matter your income. There’s plenty of room to save on top of your Plan 2 contributions.

Remember, that $60,000 Plan 2 pension in our example comes from the roughly 8% you contribute. People on Plan 3 trying to match those numbers often have to put away the full 15%. Even then, depending on the market, how they invest, and how they react to the news, it might not be enough.

With Plan 2, you usually contribute less and get more income back, and it’s guaranteed. It’s the safer play. That’s why most people who switched from 2 to 3 are kicking themselves once they see the math. Adding DCP or 403(b) savings on top of Plan 2 gives you more flexibility, and it can open the door to early retirement too.

Teachers like certainty and income that doesn’t depend on the market. If that sounds like you, Plan 2 is probably where you want to stay. Could Plan 3 come out ahead? Sure, but I haven’t seen it work out that way for anyone yet.

A red flag to watch for when getting advice

DRS can’t really advise you on this. They aren’t licensed to, and they’ll probably brush you off. So many people go to a financial advisor instead.

Advisors get paid in three main ways. They sell products for a commission, they manage your money for an investment fee, or you pay them directly for advice, by the hour or for a plan. Any of these can be fair. What matters is that you know which one applies. If you’re getting the meeting for free, there’s a good chance a product sale or an investment management pitch is coming, now or later.

If someone shows you a high rate of return turning your lump sum into a fortune, ask who benefits. They may expect some of that money to come to them. Many people who work with teachers aren’t fiduciaries. There are some really great advisors out there, but if someone is pushing you toward Plan 3, take a step back.


Frequently Asked Questions

Can I switch from TRS 2 to TRS 3 and then switch back?

No. The move from Plan 2 to Plan 3 is permanent. The state lets you go from 2 to 3, but never from 3 back to 2.

Is the lump sum DRS offers free money?

Usually not. It’s mostly the money you already paid into TRS 2, plus interest. It’s about what you’d get if you cashed out of Plan 2. In exchange, your pension factor drops from 2% to 1% per year of service.

How much would I need saved to make up the difference?

In our example, to replace $30,000 a year you’d need about $750,000 at a 4% withdrawal rate, about $600,000 at 5%, or about $514,000 to buy a TAP annuity at 62 using December 2022 rates. Those numbers just get you back to even.

If I stay on TRS 2, how can I save more for retirement?

School district employees can save into the DCP and a 403(b) on top of their Plan 2 contributions. That adds flexibility and can help with early retirement, while you keep your full 2% pension.

If you have questions about your own numbers, leave a comment on the video or reach out. Always remember that your future depends on what you do today.

P.S. It’s free to join. Over 150 members are already in it, plus you’ll get free courses and resources to help you plan your retirement with confidence.

Share this

More Articles:

Loading posts…

Your Washington Retirement Benefits, Explained

When can you retire? How much will your pension pay? What happens to your healthcare? Join our free community for Washington teachers, school staff, and public employees to explore easy-to-follow videos, ask questions, and better understand your retirement options.

7 Money Murdering Mistakes Teachers Need To Avoid

  • 3 Potential Problems Your Pension Creates that can Cause you to pay more in taxes and healthcare
  • The TRUTH about tax deferred savings & how you could end up owing over $1,000,000 in taxes!
  • Why so many teachers end up working longer than they really need to & What you can do add years to your retirement