One question we hear all the time from people getting ready to retire is simple: which account should I take money from first? You’ve spent years saving in a pension, a 403(b), a DCP, maybe a Roth IRA or a regular investment account. Now it’s time to actually spend that money, and the order you pull from those accounts can change how much of it you get to keep.
Before you can answer the “which one first” question, you need to understand one thing. The main thing that separates all of your retirement accounts is taxes. That’s the common thread. In this article, we’ll walk through the three ways retirement money gets taxed, the hidden “shadow taxes” that catch a lot of retirees off guard, and how to decide where to pull money from each year.
Why taxes decide which account you use first
Almost every money move you make has some kind of tax attached to it. Taking money out of a retirement account is no different. So the first question to ask before you withdraw anything is: what will taking money from this account do to my tax bill?
Think of your savings like water stored in three different tanks. Each tank has a different kind of faucet. One faucet charges you a fee every time you turn it on. One is free to use. One only charges you for part of what comes out. If you need a glass of water, it makes sense to know which faucet costs what before you start pouring.
For retirement accounts, there are usually three ways your money gets taxed. We call these the three tax buckets.
The 3 tax buckets for retirement money
Bucket 1: Pre-tax accounts
For most Washington state employees, these are accounts like your Plan 3 investment account, your 403(b), and your DCP (the state’s Deferred Compensation Program). Money went into these accounts before taxes were taken out. You got a tax break along the way, but you haven’t paid tax on that money yet.
That bill comes due later. When you take money out in retirement, every dollar you withdraw gets added to your taxable income for that year. You pay tax based on whatever the tax rates are at that time, not the rates from when you put the money in.
Bucket 2: Tax-free accounts
These are mainly your Roth accounts: a Roth IRA, the Roth DCP, and a Roth 403(b). With a Roth, you already paid taxes on the money when you put it in. Because of that, the money can come out tax-free later, including all the growth, as long as you follow the Roth rules (generally being at least 59½ and having the account open for five years).
This bucket is powerful because withdrawals from it don’t add to your taxable income. That matters a lot, as you’ll see when we get to shadow taxes.
Bucket 3: Taxable investment (brokerage) accounts
Maybe you opened an account through an app like Robinhood, or your advisor set one up for you, and it holds stocks, bonds, or funds. These are regular brokerage accounts. You already paid taxes on the money when you first put it in, so you only pay tax on the gains.
How those gains are taxed depends on how long you held the investment. If you held it for a year or less, it’s a short-term gain. Short-term gains are taxed at your ordinary income rate, the same rate you pay on your pension and pre-tax withdrawals. If you held it for more than a year, it’s a long-term gain, and long-term rates are usually lower than ordinary income rates.
The three buckets side by side
| Bucket | Common examples | When you paid tax | What’s taxed when you withdraw |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pre-tax | Plan 3 investment account, 403(b), DCP | Not yet | Every dollar, at ordinary income rates |
| Tax-free | Roth IRA, Roth DCP, Roth 403(b) | When you put the money in | Nothing, if you follow the Roth rules |
| Taxable brokerage | Individual or joint investment account | When you put the money in | Only the gains (short-term or long-term rates) |
So step one is simple: make a list of every account you have and write down which bucket it belongs in. Once that’s organized, you can start thinking about which one to use in a given year.
A worked example: same $30,000, very different tax bills
Let’s make this concrete. Say you need an extra $30,000 this year on top of your pension to cover your living costs. Here’s how much of that $30,000 shows up as taxable income depending on where you take it from. (This is a simplified example to show how the buckets work, not a full tax calculation.)
| Where the $30,000 comes from | Added to taxable income | How it’s taxed |
|---|---|---|
| All from pre-tax (403(b) or DCP) | $30,000 | Ordinary income rates |
| All from Roth IRA | $0 | Tax-free |
| $15,000 pre-tax + $15,000 Roth | $15,000 | Ordinary income rates on the pre-tax half only |
| Sell brokerage stock bought for $20,000, held 3 years | $10,000 gain | Long-term capital gains rates |
You spend the same $30,000 in every row. But the amount the IRS gets to count as income ranges from $0 to the full $30,000. That’s why the order you withdraw in matters so much.
Watch out for “shadow taxes”
Once you know your buckets, the next step is to look at your own situation. What tax bracket are you in right now? And just as important, are you close to triggering any shadow taxes?
Shadow taxes are the extra costs that kick in when your income gets too high. They don’t show up as a line called “shadow tax” on your return. Instead, they sneak in through other programs, like Social Security and Medicare. Here are the two big ones.
Shadow tax #1: More of your Social Security gets taxed
How much of your Social Security benefit is taxed depends on something called provisional income. In plain terms, provisional income is your other income plus half of your Social Security benefit. The higher that number, the more of your benefit becomes taxable, up to 85% of it.
For a married couple filing jointly, taxes on Social Security start once provisional income goes above $32,000, and a bigger share becomes taxable above $44,000. Those limits aren’t adjusted for inflation, so more retirees cross them every year.
Here’s a quick example. A married couple gets $30,000 a year from Social Security and has $25,000 of other income. Their provisional income is $25,000 plus half of $30,000, which is $40,000. Now they pull an extra $10,000 out of a 403(b). Their provisional income jumps to $50,000, past the $44,000 line. More of their Social Security is now taxable, so they keep less of it.
If they had pulled that same $10,000 from a Roth IRA instead, their provisional income would have stayed at $40,000. Roth withdrawals don’t count toward it.
Shadow tax #2: Medicare surcharges (IRMAA)
Medicare has income-based surcharges, often called IRMAA. If your income goes over certain limits, you pay higher premiums for Medicare Part B and Part D. If you’re married, both you and your spouse pay the higher premiums.
The tricky part is that these limits work like a cliff. Go over by just one dollar and you jump into the higher premium level. Medicare also looks back at your tax return from two years earlier to set your premiums. So a big pre-tax withdrawal this year can raise what you pay for Medicare down the road.
That’s why it’s important to think before you just start pulling money out of pre-tax accounts. The tax you see on your return may not be the whole cost.
So which account should you take from first?
The answer depends on the tax environment you’re in and where you think taxes are headed. There’s no single order that’s right for everyone every year. But here’s how we think about it.
When taxes are low: lean on pre-tax money
Tax rates today are fairly low for most people. If we think taxes may go up later, it often makes sense to take more money out of pre-tax accounts now. You’ll owe tax on that money someday no matter what. If today’s rates are lower than future rates, paying now means paying less overall.
Think of it like buying something you know you’ll need while it’s on sale. If the price is likely to go up, why wait?
When taxes are high: lean on Roth or brokerage money
Now picture the opposite. If tax rates go up in the future, you might take less from your pre-tax accounts and tap more into your Roth instead. That way you avoid paying tax at a high rate. You might also pull from a brokerage account, where you only pay tax on the gains. Then, when taxes come back down, you can shift back to your pre-tax money.
To put simple numbers on it: if your tax rate is 20%, pulling from pre-tax accounts might be a good deal. If rates ever climbed to something like 50%, you’d much rather pull from your Roth or your brokerage account and leave the pre-tax money alone until rates drop.
Mixing buckets gives you control
When you have money in more than one bucket, you get to pick and choose each year. That lets you manage your taxes, legally of course. Some years you might take a little from each. For example, you could pull from pre-tax accounts up to the top of a lower tax bracket, then cover the rest from your Roth so you don’t spill into a higher bracket or trigger a Medicare surcharge.
- Look at your tax bracket for this year and how much room is left in it.
- Check how close you are to the Social Security and Medicare income limits.
- Decide how much to take from pre-tax, how much from Roth, and how much from brokerage.
- Revisit the plan every year, because tax laws and your income will change.
What if all your money is in one bucket?
A lot of people head into retirement with all their savings in one place. Maybe everything is in your Plan 3 account, or in your Plan 3 plus the DCP. That’s all pre-tax money, so it’s really just one bucket. In that case, there isn’t much choosing to do. There’s only one way to take money out.
The good news is that it’s not too late to plan. You can still open a Roth IRA and do Roth conversions into it. A Roth conversion means moving money from a pre-tax account into a Roth. You pay tax on the amount you convert in the year you convert it. After that, the money sits in the tax-free bucket.
Doing this gives you at least two buckets: one pre-tax and one tax-free. Then, in future years, you can pick where your money comes from based on what makes sense for your taxes that year. Over a long retirement, that flexibility can save you real money.
Why many people get help with this
If all this tax stuff sounds overwhelming, that’s okay. It’s probably not what you spent your career doing. That’s why financial advisors and CPAs exist, and it’s worth talking to one before you make these decisions.
Think of it like getting a haircut. We could all cut our own hair. But we know it’ll come out much better if we go to a professional and pay them to do it right. Your life savings is no different. Paying a professional for their time gives you a much better chance of things working out in your favor.
At Scenic Financial, we work specifically with Washington state employees. We also review tax returns, so when we give advice, we already know what it will mean for your taxes before you act on it. Planning this way lets us make smarter decisions that are in your best interest. If you’d like to talk through your own withdrawal plan, you can schedule a personal meeting with us here.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which retirement account should I withdraw from first?
It depends on taxes. When tax rates are low, many people take more from pre-tax accounts like a 403(b) or DCP. When rates are high, pulling from a Roth or brokerage account can make more sense. The best order changes from year to year.
Are Plan 3, 403(b), and DCP withdrawals taxable?
Yes, for the pre-tax portion. Money in these accounts hasn’t been taxed yet, so withdrawals are added to your taxable income and taxed at ordinary income rates. Roth DCP and Roth 403(b) money is different and can come out tax-free if you follow the Roth rules.
What are shadow taxes in retirement?
Shadow taxes are extra costs that kick in when your income rises. The two most common are more of your Social Security becoming taxable and higher Medicare premiums (IRMAA). Pre-tax withdrawals can trigger both, while Roth withdrawals don’t.
How are brokerage account withdrawals taxed?
You only pay tax on the gains. If you held the investment for a year or less, the gain is taxed at ordinary income rates. If you held it for more than a year, it’s a long-term gain, which is usually taxed at a lower rate.
Is it too late to do Roth conversions if I’m about to retire?
No. You can open a Roth IRA and convert pre-tax money into it before or during retirement. You’ll pay tax on what you convert that year, but it gives you a tax-free bucket to draw from later and more control over your taxes.
Remember, your future depends on what you do today. Knowing which bucket each of your accounts falls into, and how each one is taxed, is the first step toward keeping more of the money you worked so hard to save.
P.S. Want more help planning your retirement withdrawals? Join the Washington Wealth Breakthrough Community. It’s free to join. Over 150 members are already in it, plus you’ll get free courses and resources to help you plan your retirement with confidence.

