Pay Off Your Mortgage with TRS 3 or PERS 3? 5 Reasons to Think Twice

Picture walking into retirement with no house payment. No more checks to the bank every month. It’s a nice thought, and it’s one of the most common goals I hear from Washington teachers and state workers.

So people ask me this question all the time: “Can I use my TRS 3 or PERS 3 money to pay off my mortgage? Is that a good use of the funds?”

The short answer is yes, you can. The longer answer is that for most people it’s a bad idea. It usually costs far more than it saves. In this post I’ll walk through why, with real numbers, and I’ll share what happened to a client who did it anyway.


How Your Plan 3 Money Is Taxed

First, a quick refresher. If you’re in TRS 3, PERS 3, or SERS 3, you have two parts to your retirement. One part is a pension paid by your employer. The other part is an investment account that you funded with your own contributions.

That investment account is pre-tax. You didn’t pay income tax on the money when it went in. That was a nice break back then. But the IRS didn’t forget about it. They’re just waiting for you to take it out.

Think of it like a jar of cookies where the IRS owns some of the cookies. You can see 100 cookies in the jar, but maybe 24 of them belong to someone else. You only get to eat what’s left after they take their share.

Every dollar you pull out of your Plan 3 account gets added to your taxable income for that year. That one fact is behind almost every problem with using it to pay off a house.


Reason 1: You Have to Pull Out More Than You Owe

Say you have $100,000 left on your mortgage. You might think you just withdraw $100,000 and you’re done. You aren’t.

Because that money hasn’t been taxed yet, you have to take out enough to pay the mortgage and the tax bill. In real life that’s often somewhere around $130,000 to $140,000, depending on your other income and how big the withdrawal is.

Here’s a simple example. To keep the math easy, I’ll assume a flat 24% federal tax rate on the whole withdrawal. (Washington has no state income tax, which helps. A big withdrawal can also push part of it into a higher bracket, which hurts.)

ItemAmount
Mortgage balance you want to pay off$100,000
Tax rate assumed24%
Amount you must withdraw ($100,000 ÷ 0.76)About $131,600
Federal tax owed on the withdrawalAbout $31,600
Left to pay the mortgage$100,000

So to wipe out a $100,000 loan, you’d drain about $131,600 from your retirement. Over $31,000 goes straight to the IRS.

Compare That to the Interest You’d Save

Now ask yourself what the mortgage actually costs you. Most people have rates somewhere between 3% and 7%. You’d be paying 22% or 24% (or more) in taxes to get rid of a loan that charges you 3% to 7%.

Let’s put numbers on it. Say your $100,000 balance is at 4% with 15 years left. Your payment would be about $740 a month. If you kept making payments until it was paid off, you’d pay about $33,000 in total interest over those 15 years.

Paying it off today costs you about $31,600 in tax right now, in one shot. That’s almost the same as all the interest you’d ever pay, and we haven’t even counted the other costs yet. Those come next.


Reason 2: A Big Withdrawal Shrinks Your Social Security

Here’s the part almost nobody sees coming. Whether your Social Security gets taxed depends on how much other income you have that year.

If your income is low, your Social Security might not be taxed at all. As your income goes up, more of your benefit becomes taxable, up to 85% of it. A six-figure Plan 3 withdrawal can push you all the way to that top level in a single year.

Your monthly check doesn’t change. But you end up keeping less of it after taxes. So the house payoff doesn’t just cost you tax on the withdrawal. It can also raise the tax on income you were already getting.


Reason 3: Medicare Premiums Can Jump Two Years Later

Medicare also looks at your income. If your income goes over certain limits, you pay more for Part B and Part D. This extra charge is called IRMAA, which stands for Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount.

The tricky part is the timing. Medicare uses your tax return from two years ago. So a withdrawal you make this year won’t show up on your Medicare bill until two years from now.

By then, most people have forgotten all about it. They just open a letter and wonder why their premium went from about $170 a month to about $300. It feels like it came out of nowhere, but it traces right back to that one big withdrawal.

This is why I tell people that every transaction in retirement has ripple effects. Tax rules, Social Security, and Medicare are all tied together. Pull one string and the others move too.


A Real Story: The Client Who Paid Off the House Anyway

A few years back we worked with a client who was set on doing this. We walked them through the downsides. They didn’t care. They said they didn’t need the money for anything else, and they wanted the house paid off.

So they did it. At first it felt great. The mortgage was gone.

Then the tax bill showed up. They had to dip into their savings to pay it. Next, they noticed their Social Security was netting them less, because the extra income made more of it taxable. A couple of years after that, their Medicare premiums went up too.

Every one of those surprises came from the same decision. None of them showed up on the day they paid off the house.


Reason 4: Your Money Gets Stuck in the House

Once you put that money into your home, it turns into home equity. Equity is real wealth, but it’s hard to get at.

If you need cash later for a new roof, a medical bill, or helping a family member, you can’t just pull it out of the walls. You’d have to do one of these:

  • Take out a home equity line of credit (a HELOC)
  • Do a cash-out refinance
  • Get a reverse mortgage
  • Sell the house

Every one of those takes time. Most come with fees and a pile of paperwork. Some mean borrowing money again, which defeats the point of paying off the mortgage.

Money sitting in your Plan 3 account, on the other hand, is something you can reach when you need it. In retirement, having cash you can get to quickly is a big deal. Locking a large share of your savings inside your house takes that flexibility away.


Reason 5: You Give Up Decades of Growth

This might be the biggest cost of all, and it’s the easiest one to miss.

Yes, your house will probably go up in value over time. But over long stretches, homes usually don’t grow as fast as a diversified stock portfolio. And your house goes up in value whether the mortgage is paid off or not. Paying it off doesn’t make it grow any faster.

Remember, retiring doesn’t mean your portfolio stops growing. You stop adding to it, so it may grow more slowly. But you still own the investments, and when they go up in value, so does your account. That could go on for 20, 30, even 40 years.

Here’s what that missed growth can look like. This assumes the $131,600 you would have withdrawn stays invested and earns an average of 6% a year instead. Real returns go up and down, so treat this as an illustration, not a promise.

Years Left InvestedValue at 6% Average GrowthGrowth You’d Give Up
Today$131,600$0
10 yearsAbout $235,700About $104,100
20 yearsAbout $422,000About $290,400
30 yearsAbout $755,800About $624,200

Compare that to the roughly $33,000 in mortgage interest from our earlier example. You’d be giving up a couple hundred thousand dollars or more of future growth to save a few thousand dollars a year in interest. That’s a bad trade for most people.


The Worst-Case Outcome: Running Out of Money

I’ve seen this go about as badly as it can. One client cashed out to pay off their home against our advice. They acted on emotion. About three or four years into retirement, they had run out of money.

Today, outside of their pension and Social Security, all they have is what’s in their savings, and that isn’t much. They have a paid-off house, but no cushion. If something big breaks or a health issue comes up, their options are limited.

I share that story because this mistake is avoidable. One of the simplest ways to keep from running out of money in retirement is to not drain your Plan 3 account to pay off the house.


What to Do Instead If You Want the House Paid Off

Wanting a paid-off house is a fine goal. The problem is paying for it with one huge pre-tax withdrawal. There are better ways to get there:

  • Make extra principal payments while you’re still working. Even an extra $100 or $200 a month can cut years off a loan.
  • Use after-tax savings if you have plenty. Money that’s already been taxed doesn’t create a new tax bill when you spend it.
  • Spread withdrawals out over several years. Smaller withdrawals can keep you in a lower tax bracket and away from the Medicare surcharge limits.
  • Keep the mortgage. If your rate is low, paying it as scheduled from your monthly income is often the cheapest choice.

The right answer depends on your pension, your savings, your tax bracket, and when you plan to start Social Security and Medicare. If you want help running the numbers on your own situation, you can schedule a personal meeting with us here.


Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use my TRS 3 or PERS 3 account to pay off my mortgage?

Yes. Once you’ve separated from service, you can withdraw from your Plan 3 investment account and use the money however you want, including paying off your home. The real question is whether the taxes and lost growth are worth it. For most people they aren’t.

How much do I need to withdraw to pay off a $100,000 mortgage?

More than $100,000. Because the withdrawal is taxed as income, you’ll often need around $130,000 to $140,000 to end up with $100,000 after taxes. The exact amount depends on your tax bracket and other income that year.

Will a large Plan 3 withdrawal affect my Medicare premiums?

It can. Medicare bases your Part B and Part D premiums on your income from two years earlier. A big withdrawal can push you over the IRMAA limits and raise your premiums two years later.

Does withdrawing from Plan 3 make my Social Security taxable?

It can make more of it taxable. Up to 85% of your Social Security benefit can be taxed depending on your total income. A large withdrawal raises your income for that year, which can increase how much of your benefit gets taxed.

Is it ever a good idea to pay off my house with retirement money?

There are rare cases where it might make sense, like a very high interest rate combined with an unusually low-income year. But those situations need careful math. For most Washington public employees, it costs more than it saves.

Does this apply to SERS 3 too?

Yes. SERS 3 works the same way as TRS 3 and PERS 3. The investment side of the plan is pre-tax, so the same tax, Social Security, and Medicare issues apply.


The Bottom Line

A paid-off house feels safe. But using your TRS 3, PERS 3, or SERS 3 account to get there usually means a big tax bill, less take-home Social Security, higher Medicare premiums, money stuck in your home, and decades of lost growth.

Before you make a move like this, run the numbers or talk it through with someone who knows how Washington’s plans work. Your future depends on what you do today.

P.S. It’s free to join. Over 150 members are already in it, plus you’ll get free courses and resources to help you plan your retirement with confidence.

Share this

More Articles:

Loading posts…

Your Washington Retirement Benefits, Explained

When can you retire? How much will your pension pay? What happens to your healthcare? Join our free community for Washington teachers, school staff, and public employees to explore easy-to-follow videos, ask questions, and better understand your retirement options.

7 Money Murdering Mistakes Teachers Need To Avoid

  • 3 Potential Problems Your Pension Creates that can Cause you to pay more in taxes and healthcare
  • The TRUTH about tax deferred savings & how you could end up owing over $1,000,000 in taxes!
  • Why so many teachers end up working longer than they really need to & What you can do add years to your retirement