Has anyone ever pitched you the “pension maximization strategy”? It comes up every so often, usually from a life insurance agent or an advisor who sells insurance. On paper it sounds clever. In practice, I have almost never seen it work out well for a Washington State employee.
In this post I’ll explain what the strategy is, walk through the real numbers from an actual DRS benefit estimate, and show you the two big reasons it usually falls apart. That way, if someone brings this idea to your kitchen table, you’ll know which questions to ask before you sign anything.
What is the pension maximization strategy?
When you retire from a Washington pension like PERS, TRS, or SERS, you have to pick a payout option. Option 1 pays you the biggest monthly check, but the payments stop when you die. The survivor options pay you a little less each month, and in return your spouse keeps getting a check after you’re gone.
The pension maximization idea goes like this. You take the full Option 1 benefit and skip the survivor protection. Then you take the extra money you get each month and use it to buy a private life insurance policy. If you die first, your spouse gets a tax-free lump sum from the insurance company, and that lump sum is supposed to replace the pension income they lost.
Think of it like this. Picking a survivor option is really a way of buying life insurance from DRS. You “pay” for it by accepting a smaller check. The pension max pitch says you can buy that same protection cheaper somewhere else. The whole question is whether that’s actually true.
Running the numbers on a real DRS benefit estimate
Let’s use a real retirement benefit estimate one of my clients got earlier this year. Their full Option 1 benefit was $4,347 per month. If they chose Option 2, the joint and 100% survivor option, their check would drop to $3,482 per month. Under Option 2, if they pass away, their spouse keeps getting the full $3,482 for life.
Salespeople usually compare against Option 2 because it’s the lowest monthly payout. That makes the gap as big as possible, which leaves the most money to spend on insurance premiums. Here’s what that gap looks like.
| Pension Option | Monthly Benefit | What Happens When You Die |
|---|---|---|
| Option 1 (full benefit) | $4,347 | Payments stop |
| Option 2 (100% survivor) | $3,482 | Spouse keeps $3,482 for life |
| Difference | $865 | This is the “premium budget” for the pension max strategy |
So the pitch is: take the $4,347, and instead of “giving” $865 a month to the state, send that $865 to a life insurance company. Sounds reasonable. Now let’s see whether $865 a month can actually buy enough coverage.
Step 1: How much life insurance would you need?
Instead of starting with “how much insurance can I buy,” start with “how much insurance do I need.” Your spouse would need to replace that $3,482 a month. Over a year, that’s $41,784. To keep things simple, we’ll ignore cost-of-living adjustments for now. We’ll come back to those, because they matter a lot.
Your spouse gets a lump sum from the insurance company. They’d invest it and pull money out each year. How big the lump sum has to be depends on how much they can safely withdraw each year. You find the answer by dividing the yearly income by the withdrawal rate.
| Withdrawal Rate | Math | Lump Sum Needed |
|---|---|---|
| 4% | $41,784 ÷ 0.04 | About $1,044,600 |
| 5% | $41,784 ÷ 0.05 | About $835,700 |
| 6% | $41,784 ÷ 0.06 | About $696,400 |
A 4% withdrawal rate is a common rule of thumb for money that has to last a long time. At 4%, your spouse would need just over $1 million. If you assume they can earn more and pull out 5%, you need about $835,000. The higher the withdrawal rate you assume, the less insurance you need. But a higher withdrawal rate also means more risk that the money runs out.
Step 2: You have to qualify first
Life insurance isn’t like car or home insurance, where you pay and you’re covered. You have to qualify medically. The insurance company will usually want a medical exam, health records, and a long list of questions. Your health can push your premium up, or it can get you turned down completely.
The pension option is different. DRS doesn’t care about your blood pressure. Anyone can choose a survivor option, and the price is already built into the benefit estimate.
Step 3: It has to be permanent insurance
Term life insurance is cheap, but it’s temporary. You’re basically renting coverage for 10, 20, or 30 years. If you give up your survivor benefit and then outlive your term policy, your spouse ends up with nothing. That’s the worst possible result. So for this strategy, you’d need permanent insurance, like whole life.
Step 4: Compare the premium to the $865
I looked up average whole life insurance rates from a survey of about 14 policies across different companies. For someone in their 50s, a $500,000 policy ran about $1,000 a month for men and about $837 a month for women. That’s for half a million dollars, which we already know isn’t enough.
A $1 million policy was roughly $2,100 a month or more. Here’s how that lines up against the $865 you’d free up by taking Option 1.
| Item | Monthly Amount |
|---|---|
| Extra pension from taking Option 1 | $865 |
| Whole life premium, $1 million, age 50s (approx.) | $2,100+ |
| Shortfall you’d pay out of pocket | About $1,235 or more |
The $865 doesn’t even cover half the premium. That’s problem number one. The amount you give up for a survivor option usually isn’t big enough to buy a private policy that does the same job.
What about cheaper policies?
Some permanent policies cost less than whole life. Variable and indexed policies can have lower premiums up front. But there’s a catch. Whole life costs more because it gives you the most guarantees: a guaranteed premium and a guaranteed interest rate.
With variable or indexed policies, the internal costs can rise as you get older. You’re counting on the investment side of the policy to grow enough to cover those rising costs. If it doesn’t, you either pay more out of pocket or the policy can lapse. You’re taking on that risk, which is why the policy is cheaper. If I were going to consider this strategy at all, I would only use whole life. And as the numbers show, whole life usually doesn’t fit.
Problem number two: your pension grows and your insurance doesn’t
Say you found a case where the premium did fit inside the $865. There’s still a second problem. Washington’s Plan 2 and Plan 3 pensions come with cost-of-living adjustments, or COLAs. Each year, your benefit can go up with inflation, up to 3%. So the numbers we ran today will be different a year from now, because your check will be bigger.
Most life insurance policies pay a level death benefit. If you buy $1 million, it stays $1 million. It doesn’t grow each year. Meanwhile, the income your spouse would need keeps climbing. Here’s what happens if the survivor benefit grows the full 3% every year.
| Year of Retirement | Survivor Pension (Monthly) | Survivor Pension (Yearly) | Lump Sum Needed at 4% |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $3,482 | $41,784 | About $1.04 million |
| Year 10 | About $4,543 | About $54,520 | About $1.36 million |
| Year 20 | About $6,106 | About $73,270 | About $1.83 million |
By year 20, a $1 million policy would replace only a little over half of what the pension would have paid your spouse. Every year that goes by, the insurance falls further behind. A dollar today buys more than a dollar will in 20 years, and the level death benefit can’t keep up.
Some policies do offer an increasing death benefit. But that feature costs a lot more. If the level policy was already out of reach at $865 a month, the increasing version won’t be anywhere close.
What most pitches leave out
Beyond the math, the pension survivor option has a few advantages a private policy can’t match:
- No medical underwriting. You don’t have to pass an exam to get survivor coverage through DRS.
- No bills to keep paying. The cost comes out of your check automatically. When money gets tight, life insurance premiums are often the first thing people cut. If the policy lapses, your spouse has no protection and you’ve already given up the survivor benefit.
- Built-in inflation protection. The survivor benefit keeps getting COLAs. Most policies don’t.
- Less that can go wrong. You don’t have to worry about an insurance company’s financial health or a policy performing worse than the illustration.
- Less work. No paperwork, no annual reviews of a policy, no premium due dates.
Also keep in mind that once you start your pension, your option choice is generally locked in. If you skip the survivor benefit and the insurance plan doesn’t work out, you usually can’t go back and add it. That’s why it’s worth getting this decision right the first time. If you’d like someone to look at your own benefit estimate with you, you can schedule a personal meeting here.
When could pension max work?
There is one situation where it might make sense. If you already bought a large permanent policy when you were young, in your 30s or 40s, your premium may be much lower than what you’d give up for the survivor option. If what you’re already paying is well below that $865 gap, and the policy is big enough to cover your spouse, the strategy at least has a chance.
Some people also point out that life insurance death benefits are tax-free, while pension checks are taxed. That’s true. Your spouse wouldn’t need to replace the full pre-tax $41,784, because part of the pension would have gone to taxes anyway. So you could get by with a somewhat smaller policy.
But even after adjusting for taxes, the COLA problem doesn’t go away. The pension keeps growing. The level death benefit doesn’t. For most Washington State employees retiring in their 50s or 60s and buying a new policy, the numbers still don’t work.
What to ask if someone pitches this to you
If an advisor or insurance agent brings up pension maximization, treat it as a red flag. That doesn’t mean they’re a bad person. It means you should slow down and check their work. Here are a few questions to ask:
- How much income does my spouse actually need, and what withdrawal rate are you assuming?
- Is this permanent insurance, and are the premiums guaranteed?
- What happens to the policy if the investments inside it don’t perform?
- How does the death benefit keep up with my pension’s COLA?
- What happens if I can’t afford the premium in 10 years?
- Have I qualified medically, and at what rating?
Before you change anything, get a second and even a third opinion. This choice affects your spouse for the rest of their life, and it’s very hard to undo.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a pension maximization strategy?
It means taking your pension’s full, single-life payout instead of a survivor option, then using the extra monthly income to buy life insurance. The insurance is meant to replace your pension for your spouse if you die first.
Why doesn’t pension max usually work for Washington State employees?
Two main reasons. First, the monthly difference between Option 1 and a survivor option usually isn’t enough to pay for a big enough permanent policy. Second, Washington Plan 2 and Plan 3 pensions get COLAs, while most life insurance pays a fixed amount that loses value to inflation over time.
Can I use term life insurance for pension maximization?
It’s risky. Term insurance ends after a set number of years. If you outlive the term, your spouse gets no insurance payout and no survivor pension. For this strategy to even have a chance, you’d need permanent coverage.
How much life insurance would I need to replace my pension?
Divide the yearly survivor income by a safe withdrawal rate. For a $41,784 yearly survivor benefit, that’s about $1.04 million at 4% or about $835,700 at 5%. Because the pension grows with COLAs, the amount you’d truly need goes up every year.
Is there any case where pension max makes sense?
Possibly, if you already own a large permanent policy that you bought young and the premium is far below what you’d give up for the survivor option. Even then, run the numbers carefully, including taxes and COLAs, before you waive the survivor benefit.
The bottom line
The pension maximization strategy sounds like a smart way to get the bigger check and still protect your spouse. For most Washington State employees, though, the survivor option from DRS costs less and carries less risk. It keeps up with inflation, needs no health exam, and has no premiums you might struggle to pay later.
If someone shows you a pension max plan, take your time. Ask for the full math, compare it against your actual DRS benefit estimate, and talk to a couple of other people before you make a decision you can’t take back.
P.S. It’s free to join. Over 150 members are already in it, plus you’ll get free courses and resources to help you plan your retirement with confidence.

