For years, Washington’s Deferred Compensation Program (DCP) only had one flavor: pre-tax. You put money in, got a tax break today, and paid the tax later when you pulled it out in retirement. Then the state announced that a Roth option was coming, with an official start date of October 1, 2023. It also said you would be allowed to convert money you already had in pre-tax DCP over to the Roth side.
That was a big deal. Before this, a lot of the tax planning we do with Roth money had to wait until a person retired and rolled their DCP out. Now you can start while you are still working. In this post, I’ll walk through the rules the state published, point out a few spots where you need to be careful, and show some simple examples so you can decide if Roth DCP makes sense for you.
Roth DCP basics: pay tax now, not later
Think of taxes on your retirement savings like a toll road. With pre-tax DCP, you skip the toll at the on-ramp, but you pay it at the off-ramp when you take the money out. With Roth DCP, you pay the toll at the on-ramp. After that, the money grows, and when you exit in retirement, there is no toll at all, as long as you follow the rules.
Here is what that means in plain numbers. Roth contributions do not lower your taxable income today. Your Roth DCP percentage is taken from your gross pay, and you still pay income tax on your whole paycheck. The payoff comes later, when the growth can come out tax-free.
A paycheck example
Say you earn $5,000 a month and put $1,000 into DCP. Here is how the two options compare on that one paycheck.
| Item | Pre-tax DCP | Roth DCP |
|---|---|---|
| Gross monthly pay | $5,000 | $5,000 |
| DCP contribution | $1,000 | $1,000 |
| Pay subject to income tax | $4,000 | $5,000 |
| Tax on withdrawals later | Yes, on all of it | No, if the rules are met |
The percentage is figured on gross pay. If you pick 10% Roth on a $5,000 salary, $500 goes into Roth DCP. The state does not take taxes out first and then figure 10% of what is left. That keeps the math simple.
The Roth choice won’t change your tax bill this year. Putting $10, $1,000, or $10,000 into Roth does nothing to your taxes today. It is a long-term play that pays off in the future.
Rule 1: every DCP employer has to offer it
Roth is required for all employers in the program. No employer can opt out. If your employer offers DCP, it has to offer the Roth option too. That covers school districts, cities, and state agencies alike.
Rule 2: employer money stays pre-tax
Your own contributions can go Roth. But if your employer puts money into your DCP account, that money still goes in pre-tax, and the employer can’t split it. So even if you make every one of your contributions Roth, and convert everything you can, there will always be a slice of your account that is pre-tax. You’ll pay tax on that slice someday, either when you withdraw it or when you convert it.
Rule 3: you can split your own contributions
You, the employee, get to choose. You can put all your money on the pre-tax side, all of it on the Roth side, or some on each. The one catch is the IRS yearly limit. That limit covers both sides added together, and it changes every year.
To keep the numbers round, imagine a yearly limit of $30,000 (check the IRS for the real number each year). You could not put $30,000 into Roth and another $30,000 into pre-tax. Here are some ways you could split it instead:
| Choice | Pre-tax | Roth | Total | Allowed? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All pre-tax | $30,000 | $0 | $30,000 | Yes |
| Mostly Roth | $10,000 | $20,000 | $30,000 | Yes |
| Mostly pre-tax | $20,000 | $10,000 | $30,000 | Yes |
| Max both sides | $30,000 | $30,000 | $60,000 | No, over the limit |
Rule 4: you have to sign up for Roth yourself
Roth does not turn on by itself. If you want it, you need to log in to the online system and change your contribution from pre-tax to Roth. If your employer auto-enrolls new workers in DCP, that money goes in pre-tax by default, which is standard in the industry. You can switch to Roth at any time.
There is a minimum of $30 per side. If you just want to dip a toe in, $30 is enough to get started, but you have to pick pre-tax or Roth for it. If you want to split, you need at least $30 on each side. You can also pick percentages, and they do not have to match. For example, 1% Roth and 3% pre-tax is fine.
Rule 5: changes can take up to 30 days
You can change your choice whenever you want, but DCP says changes may take up to 30 days to kick in. Slow updates are one of the biggest complaints I hear from people already in the plan. They make a contribution change, and it just doesn’t show up for a while.
If simple contribution changes are slow, conversions may be slower. If you want a conversion to count for a certain tax year, it has to be done before December 31. So start the paperwork in October. Don’t wait until November or December and hope it goes through in time.
Rule 6: the five-year rule starts on January 1
Everyone says Roth money grows tax-free and comes out tax-free. That’s true, but only after you meet the five-year rule. The clock starts with your first Roth contribution. You have to wait at least five years before the growth counts as tax-free. Your contributions can come out any time without tax, because you already paid tax on them. It’s the growth that has to wait.
The state’s handout says the five-year clock starts on your contribution date. That is not how it works. The IRS counts by tax year. No matter what day of the year you make your first Roth contribution, it counts as if you made it on January 1 of that year.
| First Roth contribution | What the handout implies | How the IRS counts it |
|---|---|---|
| October 31, 2023 | Clock done October 31, 2028 | Clock done January 1, 2028 |
| Any day in 2024 | Five years from that day | Clock done January 1, 2029 |
That is almost a full year of difference in the first example. Hopefully the state fixes the wording. Either way, it pays to know the real rule.
Retiring soon? Watch the clock
Say you start Roth DCP this year and retire next year. Any growth in that Roth account still isn’t tax-free yet. You have to wait out the five years. There are also no special exceptions for emergencies. The IRS rules are pretty black and white. If you haven’t met the five-year rule, you pay tax on the growth that comes out.
Moving Roth DCP to a Roth IRA can reset the clock
Roth IRAs have their own five-year rule. Picture this: you’ve had Roth DCP for 10 years. You leave your job and open a brand-new Roth IRA to roll the money into. Because the Roth IRA is brand new, its clock starts over. Now you have to wait another five years before the growth in that account counts as tax-free.
The fix is to start a Roth IRA clock early. But you can’t just open an empty Roth IRA and let it sit for five years. A contribution is what starts the clock. Roth IRA contributions also have income limits. If you earn too much, you may need a backdoor Roth strategy, which has its own list of steps to get right.
Rule 7: Roth conversions are allowed, with no take-backs
You can move money you already have on the pre-tax side of DCP over to the Roth side. You’ll pay tax on the amount you convert in the year you do it. To convert, you contact the DCP record keeper or fill out a conversion request form. Turn it in early. Even with large firms, a conversion can take a couple of weeks to get through the system.
Once a conversion goes through, it is final. The same goes for contributions. You can’t change your mind later and switch Roth money back to pre-tax. If you find out down the road that the conversion pushed your tax bill higher than you expected, there is no undo button. That’s why it helps to run the numbers before you send the form.
Double-check your tax forms
This was brand new for DCP, so staff had to learn how to handle Roth money, and mistakes can happen. I’ve seen other employers with Roth options report the wrong numbers on tax forms. If you catch it early, it’s no big deal. If the IRS catches it first, you get one of those letters in the mail.
If you take money from both sides, you’ll get two separate 1099-R forms. The Roth one will still show the money that came out, even if you owe no tax on it. Look for the taxable amount. It should say zero. The withdrawal still gets reported to the IRS, but it is not counted as taxable income.
Rule 8: Roth money can’t buy an annuity or service credit
Using Roth money to buy lifetime income that is tax-free sounds nice. But the state says no. Only pre-tax money can be used for that. This matters if you were planning to use DCP money to buy an annuity through DRS, or to purchase service credit for your pension.
If that’s part of your plan, you might hold off on converting. Keep enough pre-tax money in DCP to cover the purchase you have in mind.
Rule 9: you can invest the two sides differently
When you first enroll, the Roth side and pre-tax side have to use the same investment choices. After that, you can set them up differently. That opens the door to a smart move.
Don’t think of these as two separate accounts. Think of them as two parts of one portfolio. Roth growth is tax-free, so it usually makes sense to hold your more aggressive investments, like stocks, on the Roth side. Those are the ones most likely to grow. Bonds grow a little, but not a lot, so they fit better on the pre-tax side. Slower growth there means a smaller tax bill down the road.
| Account side | Holds mostly | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Roth DCP | Stock funds (the “60” in a 60/40 mix) | Biggest expected growth, and that growth is tax-free |
| Pre-tax DCP | Bond funds (the “40”) | Slower growth keeps the future tax bill smaller |
Roth DCP vs. Roth IRA
The state’s answer to this question is short: Roth IRAs have income limits and Roth DCP doesn’t, and DCP has a higher contribution limit. Both are true. But there is more to it.
- A Roth IRA is an individual account. You can pick almost any investment you want: individual stocks, index funds, mutual funds, even crypto.
- DCP is run by the Washington State Investment Board, and you can only use its short list of funds.
- With so few funds, it’s hard to build a well-spread-out portfolio. Most of my clients’ portfolios hold anywhere from 20 to 40 investments covering different parts of the world.
- Both accounts have a five-year rule, and each one has its own clock.
You can roll Roth DCP money out to a Roth IRA or another employer’s Roth plan when you leave your job. DCP also accepts Roth rollovers in. For example, you could move an old Roth 403(b) into DCP. You’d lose that old plan’s investment choices and loan features, though, so think about whether it is really in your best interest first.
Roth rules have a lot of moving parts, and they change. If you want someone to look at your own situation before you make a move, you can schedule a personal meeting with us here. It’s worth having guidance at least the first time, because a mistake with taxes can affect your other benefits.
Frequently Asked Questions
When did Roth DCP start in Washington?
The state set the official start date as October 1, 2023. Conversions of existing pre-tax DCP money to Roth were allowed as part of the launch.
Does Roth DCP lower my taxes this year?
No. Roth contributions come out of your gross pay, and you still pay income tax on your full paycheck. The benefit is tax-free growth later, once you meet the five-year rule.
Can I do both Roth and pre-tax DCP?
Yes. You can split your contributions any way you like, with at least $30 on each side. The total of both sides has to stay under the IRS yearly limit.
Can I undo a Roth conversion in DCP?
No. Once the conversion goes through, it can’t be reversed. The same is true for Roth contributions.
Can I use Roth DCP money to buy a DRS annuity or service credit?
According to the state, no. Those purchases have to use pre-tax money. If you plan to make one, keep enough on the pre-tax side before you convert.
When should I turn in a conversion request?
Early. Changes can take up to 30 days, and a conversion has to be finished by December 31 to count for that tax year. October is a good time to start.
Roth DCP gives Washington public employees a way to start tax planning years before retirement. Pick your split, get the paperwork in early, watch the five-year clock, and put your fastest-growing investments on the Roth side. Remember, your future depends on what you do today.
P.S. It’s free to join. Over 150 members are already in it, plus you’ll get free courses and resources to help you plan your retirement with confidence.

