Almost every Washington teacher has heard the same advice: save pre-tax now, because you’ll be in a lower tax bracket when you retire. It sounds reasonable. You make more money while you work, you make less when you stop, so you skip the tax today and pay it later at a cheaper rate.
Here’s the problem. That advice was built for people who don’t have a pension. Only about 13% of people today are entitled to a pension. If you’re in TRS 2 or TRS 3, you’re in that small group, and the usual rule of thumb may not fit you at all.
This post walks through why your income probably won’t drop as much as you think, what that means for your taxes, and why some tax-free savings may belong in your plan.
Why it’s hard to get the full picture as a school employee
As a school employee in Washington, you get several retirement benefits at once. You have a state pension plan. You pay into Social Security. You can also save into supplemental accounts like the 457 (called the DCP) or a 403(b).
The catch is that no single place can explain all of them together. If you call DRS, they’ll help with your pension plan, and that’s it. They aren’t licensed to give advice beyond that.
If you’re a Plan 3 member and want help with the investment side, you can call Empower Retirement, which runs that part of the plan. But they aren’t licensed to give advice either, so you’re mostly on your own there too.
If you have savings outside the state plans, you’d go to a financial advisor. More often than not, though, that advisor won’t know how Washington’s state pension plans work or what tax effects they’ll have down the road. So the advice you get is often the same advice given to everyone else, and everyone else doesn’t have a pension.
The “lower tax bracket in retirement” idea, explained simply
Most of us save pre-tax for retirement without thinking much about it. Plan 3 contributions are pre-tax. Traditional DCP and 403(b) contributions are pre-tax. We were told to do it this way because we’ll make less money later.
Think of it like buying something on a coupon. Pre-tax saving says, “Don’t pay the tax now. Pay it later, when the price is lower.” That’s a great deal if the price really does go down. It’s a bad deal if the price stays the same or goes up.
The “price” here is your tax rate. Pre-tax only wins if your tax rate in retirement ends up lower than your tax rate today. For most Americans with no pension, that often happens, because their paycheck stops and their income falls a lot. For you, it may not.
Why a pension keeps your retirement income high
Unlike the other 87% of Americans, your income isn’t going to drop that much when you retire. Your pension typically replaces somewhere between 30% and 60% of your income, depending on your plan and how long you worked.
On top of that, Social Security replaces about 20% of your annual income on average. Add those two together and a large share of your paycheck keeps coming, for life, from guaranteed sources.
And that’s before counting anything else. If you have a spouse with their own pension and their own Social Security, add those in. Add any money you pull from your DCP, 403(b), or Plan 3 account. Even if your total income goes down a little, it often doesn’t go down enough to move you into a lower tax bracket.
A worked example: one teacher couple, before and after retirement
Let’s use simple, made-up numbers. Maria is a teacher in TRS 2 earning $90,000. Her husband, Dave, works for the state and earns $70,000. Maria retires after 30 years. In TRS 2 the pension formula is 2% times years of service, so 30 years gives her about 60% of her average pay.
| Income source | While working | In retirement |
|---|---|---|
| Maria’s salary | $90,000 | $0 |
| Dave’s salary | $70,000 | $0 |
| Maria’s TRS 2 pension (60%) | $0 | $54,000 |
| Dave’s pension | $0 | $17,500 |
| Social Security (both) | $0 | $50,000 |
| Withdrawals from 403(b)/DCP | $0 | $25,000 |
| Total income | $160,000 | $146,500 |
Their income in retirement is about 92% of what it was while they worked. That’s a small drop. Depending on deductions and how much of their Social Security is taxed, they could easily land in the same bracket they’re in today.
Now ask the honest question: if they aren’t changing tax brackets, why were they saving everything pre-tax? They skipped tax at one rate and will pay it back at about the same rate.
Same tax bracket means pre-tax savings is a wash
If your tax rate is the same before and after retirement, pre-tax and Roth (tax-free) savings end up giving you the same money. It’s really a wash. The table below shows why, using $10,000 of income that grows four times over many years.
| Step | Pre-tax account | Roth account |
|---|---|---|
| Income you set aside | $10,000 | $10,000 |
| Tax paid today (22%) | $0 | $2,200 |
| Amount invested | $10,000 | $7,800 |
| Value after growing 4x | $40,000 | $31,200 |
| Tax when withdrawn at 22% | $8,800 | $0 |
| Money you keep | $31,200 | $31,200 |
Same tax rate, same result. That stays true until tax rates change. If the rate you pay in retirement goes up, the pre-tax account loses ground. Here’s the same $40,000 pre-tax account at a few different future rates.
| Tax rate in retirement | Pre-tax account: money you keep | Roth account: money you keep |
|---|---|---|
| 15% (lower) | $34,000 | $31,200 |
| 22% (same) | $31,200 | $31,200 |
| 25% (higher) | $30,000 | $31,200 |
| 28% (higher) | $28,800 | $31,200 |
The Roth number never moves, because you already paid the tax. The pre-tax number depends on a tax rate nobody knows yet. For people whose income falls a lot in retirement, the top row is likely. For pension members, the middle or bottom rows are more realistic.
Will taxes go up in the future?
When the video was recorded, the tax code was written so that rates would go back up in 2026 to where they were in 2017. Since then, Congress passed a law in 2025 that kept the current brackets in place, so that scheduled jump didn’t happen. But tax law only stays put until Congress changes it again.
The bigger pressure is the national debt. If you look at the national debt clock, the number keeps going up and up. There are only two ways to slow it down: spend less or collect more revenue. Spending less doesn’t seem likely, and the main way a country collects revenue is through taxes.
So there are a lot of signs pointing toward higher taxes in the future. Nobody can promise that, but today’s rates are low compared to much of the country’s history. That makes right now a good time to think about building some tax-free wealth while the “price” of paying tax is relatively cheap.
Where Washington school employees can build tax-free savings
You don’t have to give up pre-tax saving completely. The goal is balance, so you have more than one kind of money to pull from later. Here are the common places a TRS or SERS member can add Roth savings:
- Roth DCP: the state’s 457 plan has a Roth option. You pay tax now, and qualified withdrawals later are tax-free.
- Roth 403(b): many school districts offer a Roth version of the 403(b) through the same vendors.
- Roth IRA: an account you open on your own, outside of work, if your income is under the IRS limits.
- Roth conversions: moving some pre-tax money into a Roth and paying the tax on purpose in a year when it makes sense.
Your Plan 3 member contributions are pre-tax, and that part you can’t change. That’s one more reason to think about whether your extra savings should go somewhere different. If every dollar you own is pre-tax, every dollar you pull out later gets taxed at whatever the rate is then.
A simple way to think about the mix
Picture three buckets. Your pension and Social Security are the first bucket: steady, guaranteed, and mostly taxable. Your pre-tax savings are the second bucket: flexible, but taxed when you take it out. Your Roth savings are the third bucket: flexible and tax-free.
Pension members already have a big first bucket. Stacking a big second bucket on top of it pushes your taxable income even higher in retirement. A healthy third bucket gives you money you can spend without raising your tax bill, which helps in years with a big expense like a new roof or a car.
Getting help that fits a Washington pension
This is why my partner and I created Scenic Financial. We’re an independent, fiduciary, virtual advising practice that helps school employees across the state build better financial futures. We have almost ten years of experience working only with Washington state employees.
If you’d like to learn how your state pension plan works with your other benefits, and where it might make the most sense for you to save, you can schedule a personal meeting with us here. There are only a few spots available each day, and since we work with teachers across the state, the calendar gets busy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will my taxes be lower in retirement if I’m in TRS 2 or TRS 3?
Maybe not. Your pension typically replaces 30% to 60% of your income, and Social Security adds about 20% on average. With a spouse’s income and your own savings on top, many pension members stay in the same tax bracket after they retire.
Is pre-tax saving a bad idea for teachers?
No. If your tax rate stays the same, pre-tax and Roth come out even. Pre-tax only falls behind if your tax rate goes up in retirement. The risk is putting everything in pre-tax accounts, which leaves you fully exposed to whatever future tax rates turn out to be.
Can DRS or Empower tell me whether to use Roth or pre-tax?
No. DRS can help with questions about your pension plan, and Empower runs the investment side of Plan 3, but neither is licensed to give you advice. For a recommendation that looks at your whole picture, you’d need a financial advisor who understands Washington’s pension plans.
Are my Plan 3 contributions pre-tax?
Yes. Plan 3 member contributions go in pre-tax, so you’ll pay income tax when you withdraw them. If you want tax-free money in retirement, you’d build it with a Roth DCP, Roth 403(b), or Roth IRA instead.
Did taxes go up in 2026 like the video says?
No. The video was made when the 2017 tax cuts were set to expire after 2025. A 2025 law kept the current brackets in place. The long-term pressure from the national debt is still there, so future increases remain possible.
Remember, your future depends on what you do today. A pension is a big advantage, but it also changes the math on how you should save. Knowing that now gives you years to build a better mix.
P.S. It’s free to join. Over 150 members are already in it, plus you’ll get free courses and resources to help you plan your retirement with confidence.

