Transfer 403(b) – Don’t Make This Mistake & Pay Taxes Twice

Don’t Make This 403b Transfer Mistake & Pay Taxes Twice

When it comes to managing your retirement funds, understanding the intricacies of a 403(b) plan is crucial, especially when transferring your money to other accounts. One common mistake can lead to double taxation, costing you thousands of dollars. This guide will explain how to avoid this costly error and ensure your money is managed correctly.

Understanding 403(b) Accounts

A 403(b) plan is a retirement savings vehicle often offered to employees of public schools, tax-exempt organizations, and certain ministers. These plans are unique in that they combine pre-tax contributions and Roth contributions within a single account.

How Contributions Are Tracked

Each 403(b) account has two components:

  • Pre-tax Contributions: Money that hasn’t been taxed yet. When withdrawn, you’ll pay taxes on both the contributions and their earnings.
  • Roth Contributions: Money contributed after taxes, meaning you’ve already paid taxes on these funds. Withdrawals, including earnings, are tax-free if certain conditions are met.

The recordkeeper meticulously tracks these contributions and their respective earnings. However, complications can arise when transferring these funds to other retirement accounts.

The Mistake That Leads to Double Taxation

How It Happens

When you decide to transfer your 403(b) funds, the process must account for the two types of contributions. However, errors often occur due to oversight or confusion.

For example, if you have $100,000 in your 403(b) account, with $50,000 in pre-tax contributions and $50,000 in Roth contributions, submitting a transfer request without clear instructions can result in all funds being moved to a pre-tax IRA. This mistake effectively converts the Roth portion into pre-tax funds.

Why It’s a Problem

The IRS treats the entire amount in the IRA as pre-tax. When you withdraw the Roth portion later, you’ll be taxed again, even though taxes were already paid on that money. This is the dreaded double taxation scenario.

Avoiding the Double Taxation Trap

Best Practices for Transferring Funds

To prevent this costly error, follow these best practices:

  1. Submit Separate Transfer Forms: Send one form for pre-tax contributions and another for Roth contributions. Clearly label each transfer to ensure proper allocation.
  2. Mark Forms Clearly: If your account number isn’t separated for pre-tax and Roth contributions, write “Roth” or “Pre-tax” directly on the form to avoid confusion.
  3. Communicate With the Custodian: Call the custodian to confirm they understand your instructions. Verify that the funds are being transferred into the correct accounts.
  4. Double-Check After the Transfer: Once the transfer is complete, review your IRA accounts to ensure the funds are allocated as intended.

What to Do If an Error Occurs

If you discover that your Roth contributions were mistakenly transferred into a pre-tax IRA, act immediately:

  1. Contact the Custodian: Notify them of the mistake as soon as possible.
  2. Request a Correction: Most custodians have a process to correct such errors, but timing is critical.
  3. Follow Up Diligently: Ensure the correction is completed by confirming with both the custodian and the receiving institution.

Other Accounts to Watch For

While this mistake is most common with 403(b) accounts, it can also occur with Deferred Compensation Plans (DCPs) that include Roth contributions. Since Roth DCPs are relatively new, fewer transfers have occurred, but the potential for error exists. Always double-check the allocation of funds when transferring from these accounts.

Why Double-Checking Matters

A little diligence can save you a lot of money. By being proactive and thorough, you can ensure your retirement savings retain their tax advantages. Transferring funds from a 403(b) or DCP doesn’t have to be complicated, but mistakes can be costly if not handled correctly.

FAQs

1. Can I transfer my 403(b) funds to multiple accounts? Yes, you can transfer funds from a 403(b) to separate pre-tax and Roth IRAs. It’s crucial to ensure the proper amounts are allocated to each account to maintain their tax status.

2. What happens if I don’t catch a transfer error in time? If you don’t address a transfer error quickly, it might be irreversible. This could result in paying unnecessary taxes on your Roth contributions. Always review your accounts promptly after a transfer.

3. Are there penalties for incorrect 403(b) transfers? While there aren’t direct penalties for incorrect transfers, the financial impact can be significant due to double taxation on Roth funds.

4. Do I need a financial advisor to manage 403(b) transfers? While not required, a financial advisor can provide guidance and ensure your transfer is handled correctly, potentially saving you from costly mistakes.

5. Is it better to keep funds in a 403(b) or transfer them to an IRA? This depends on your financial goals. IRAs often provide more investment options and flexibility, but you should carefully plan any transfers to avoid errors.


P.S. Join our free community and gain exclusive access to expert financial insights, personalized tools, and step-by-step guidance tailored for Washington State employees. Whether you’re just starting out or nearing retirement, our community offers the resources you need to confidently plan your financial future. Connect with like-minded individuals, ask questions, and stay informed about the latest strategies to maximize your retirement benefits. Start your journey today and take control of your financial goals—it’s completely free!

Join our free community to unlock essential tools and expert insights for Washington State employees. Get started today and take control of your financial future! free community

Ready to start taking control of your future? Schedule a meeting with us here: Schedule a meeting with us here

Get Personalized Investment Advice on your TRS 3 & DCP Plans Get Personalized Investment Advice

Share this

More Articles:

Free Washington State Retirement Planning Community

Join our free community and gain exclusive access to expert financial insights & personalized tools tailored for Washington State employees. Whether you’re just starting out or nearing retirement, our community offers the resources you need to confidently plan your financial future. Connect with like-minded individuals, ask questions, and stay informed about the latest strategies to maximize your retirement benefits. Start your journey today and take control of your financial goals—it’s completely free!

Money Murdering Mistakes Teachers Need To Avoid

  • 3 Potential Problems Your Pension Creates that can Cause you to pay more in taxes and healthcare
  • The TRUTH about tax deferred savings & how you could end up owing over $1,000,000 in taxes!
  • Why so many teachers end up working longer than they really need to & What you can do add years to your retirement